Most potential buyers seeking an historic home in
Key West will likely be searching for a charming cottage or two story revival style home in Old Town. If they are also shopping by price, they will learn totally renovated properties will be pretty "pricey" and non-renovated places will likely be both more expensive than they envisioned and probably will require expensive renovation. The house at
1227 Washington Street offers the historic character that some buyers may find enticing. Let me tell you why.
I saw the property at a recent broker open house. An ancient Mahogany tree dominates the front yard which is 100 feet wide. The house is set back from the street in the middle of the lot. There is a wide driveway on the east side and a lap pool is hidden on the west side behind a fence an tropical foliage. The door to the front porch was open as I approached the house. As I started to enter I saw the Cuban tile floors and instantly knew I was in for a surprise. The porch has traditional wood louvers that move to moderate sun, wind, and rain. Since the front porch ensures privacy, French doors provide a novel entry into the living room. I was genuinely awed when I saw the ten foot ceilings and the expansive size of the living and adjacent ding room.
The listing Realtor told me the story of the one family who lived in this home since it was built. As I went through the house and walked around the outside I could tell the place was very well maintained throughout its existence. The kitchen and bathrooms are dated, but the interior spaces are both large and inviting. Remember I mentioned the challenges buyers face when they find a cottage or a "fixer" in Old Town - those little items like failing piers, tiny bedrooms, woeful neglect. That is not the case here. I did notice an opportunity to make the both the appearance and functionality better in a couple of places. The two single doors in the dining room open out to the side porch which overlooks the pool. I will discuss the porch and pool later. I think a new owner might replace both the windows and doors such that the entries are both on the same vertical and horizontal frame as opposed to the way they look and function now. The "look" would be better, of that I am sure.
Unlike most houses in Old Town which have small bedrooms, there are two very large bedrooms on the east side of the house which are separated by a bath. The far bedroom has an en-suite bath. A third and smaller bedroom is located just off the dining room. A large hallway takes up a substantial amount of potential usable living area. The ten foot ceilings carry throughout the house. Each of these rooms (even the third bedroom) feel quite large. Also, there is a unique walk-through closet shared by the north and third bedroom.
The kitchen was "modernized" a few decades ago. It may be time to update this space and integrate it into the other public areas of the home. Let's take a look at the outside to consider what might be done to make this home and yard more relevant modern life.
I am no architectural critic but I play one on the internet. I think the side porch overlooking the pool is less than it could be. I also think the step down the pool reflects how we lived years ago. There is a small building at the back of the lot which could be elevated and enlarged to create a poolside cabana. Perhaps the pool, porches and cabana could all be located on the same plain to create an integrated outdoor environment. In that process I would definitely replace the existing fences.
The old garage at the end of the long driveway could possibly become a new guest cottage which could replace the third (and smaller bedroom) inside the house.
CLICK HERE to view more photos of this home.
The White Street Pier and Higg's Beach are located just six blocks to the south. You can be almost anywhere in Key West in about five to seven minutes by car - except those times we are overridden by tourists who we love. Not. Maybe...
CLICK HERE to view the Key West MLS datasheet and listing photos of 1227 Washington Street, Key West which is offered for sale at $1,420,000. The listing Realtor advised me the price is "negotiable". I think every price is negotiable, even in pricey Key West. Please take a look at the MLS and then call me,
Gary Thomas,
305-766-2642, to schedule a private showing of this home. I am a buyers agent and a full time Realtor at Preferred Properties Key West. I think this place could be spectacular. Most of the money spent here will be on fun things like the kitchen and bathrooms and possibly redeveloping the cottage, garage, and pool and garden.
