1106 Pearl Street - Key West Duplex

1106 Pearl Street built in 1906

1106 Pearl Street - Key West

Today's blog is about a duplex located a couple of blocks east of Old Town one block south of Bayfront Park. The original house was built in 1906. It is presently a legal duplex. I think this property could work very well for a buyer that wants a property that could be legally rented to produce some income to help defray part of the ownership costs and which could eventually be made into a lovely Key West single family home. Many buyers want a single family house like this but settle on an easy to rent vacation rental instead. This property is an alternative that might work just right.

Living room in the rear unit

The front unit is a very clean one bedroom and one bath apartment. There is a nice fenced in front yard that provides privacy from the street. A much larger two bedroom unit sits at the rear. Together these units have 1252 sq ft of living area. The lot is a generous 3668 SQ ft or 41' X 90'. The house sits more to the left of the lot which means there is more open space on the right (or north side) for improvement. This space could be used to add a pool or deck area or garden area.

View at rear looking toward the front

Abundant room for a pool, decks, and garden

If you consider the black and white photo you will see the house has a decent pitched gable roof. The original front porch was enclosed and that space is now used as the living room in the front apartment. I could envision a new owner doing a two tier renovation of the property that would permit short term upgrades by a new owner and longer term improvements when the owner takes the property back to single family residence.

During the short term I could see adding a pool and decks to the side and rear. This would make the outdoor space much more useful and certainly much more attractive. The photo above shows the rear 'bedroom' which is currently used as an office. I would replace the single door with a French door. which would add a lot of light into the space and make the inside much more vibrant. The rear unit could be rented for a higher monthly rent until such time as the owner wanted to use the house full time.

Replace the existing door with French doors to brighten the area

Later I would eliminate the front apartment. I would re-open the now enclosed front porch which is now the living room. I would vault the ceiling throughout the house which would make the living areas much more interesting. Finally, I would add bricks to the driveway and replace the old chain link fence with a nice bright white picket fence.


1106 Pearl Street is offered at $435,000. CLICK HERE to view the Key West mls datasheet on this property. I have more photos which you can see if you CLICK HERE. You won't find a property this large with this many possibilities in Old Town. Yet Old Town is only four blocks to the west. That's a lot of potential for not a lot of money.

Please contact me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642, if you would like to see this property. I am a buyer's agent and a full time Realtor at Preferred Properties Coastal Realty, Inc.