1019 Elgin Lane, Key West - A Reinterpreted Old House

1019 Elgin Lane  Key West  2017

I wrote about 1019 Elgin Lane in April 2015 when I described is as a bank property "located in a desirable Old Town location near the Historic Seaport." I was shocked and delighted in the transformation from what was a mess into a stunning contemporary renovation. In my 2015 blog I showed the original building s it appeared in a 1965 photo and a photo I took at that time.

1019 Elgin Lane Key West  1965

1019 Elgin Lane Key West   2015

The listing Realtor describes the freshly renovated property as a

"Stunning contemporary Renovation of Elevated Historic home located on Picturesque Elgin Lane just steps from the Historic Seaport. With 3BD/3BA. the beautiful interior finishes create a luxurious beach ambiance. Soaring Ceilings combined with a Wall of Impact Doors marries the Sun Filled Patio and private Dipping Pool to living and Kitchen. Gorgeous Master on Second floor with ensuite Bath and an enviable large Walk in closet. Third bedroom is located on third floor, with beautiful views of the Key West Rooftops. With One Off Street Parking Spot, this brand Newly restored home qualifies as the Quintessential Key West Retreat."  

During the renovation process the building was elevated to comply with FEMA and building code requirements. Electric, pluming, and HVAC were replaced as were all interior wood walls, flooring, and bathrooms. A pool with waterfall plus surrounding fencing and decking were added. These features mean your insurance policies will be more affordable and your maintenance costs will be less expensive. Insulation and construction features mean your costs of electricity will also be less.

Main floor bath

The main floor bedroom is located adjacent to the staircase. The main floor bath is located off the kitchen and next to the main entry. 

Master bath

Second guest bath

The master suite is located on the second floor and it is anything but petite.  The en-suite bath has floating cabinetry and double sinks plus an extra large shower.  There is also a large walk-in closet.

The third floor bedroom runs the length of the house from south to north. This a lot of space no matter how it may appear in the photo.  I saw the house on a cloudy day (the first in a long time). But I took a couple of photos looking toward the Historic Seaport to the north and down onto Elgin Lane to the south.

Looking north to the historic seaport

Looking down onto Elgin Lane

This owner did everything right. This place is move-in ready and should sell quickly. The place has all new everything - mechanical, interiors, roof, pool, and so forth. The spaces and uses are well thought out and attractively done. The materials are contemporary in style and functionality. Most of the home on this block have been renovated in the past decade and would be considered as up graded when compared to many homes in the Old Town area. This house would make a good monthly vacation rental because of the three bedrooms, three baths, pool, and parking plus the terrific location near the seaport. 

CLICK HERE to view the Key West MLS datasheet and more listing photos of 1019 Elgin Lane Key West. Then please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642, to set up a private showing.  I think you will love this house and its great Old Town location. I am a buyers agent and a full time Realtor at Preferred Properties Key West.

1009 Watson Street, Key West

New to the Key West real estate market is 1009 Watson Street. I wrote about  this hidden gem a few years ago. It is so hidden that I cannot find the original blog. I remember the first time I saw this house several years ago. It is located down a narrow walking lane that is sandwiched between to old houses which front onto Watson Street. The house emerged at the rear as it does today but then I took in the true majesty of the location. The yard is huge by Key West standards and especially huge for being located behind two nice but non-assuming houses. I searched in my old shoebox and found a photo of the front houses and the walkway of fifty plus years ago.

The original house has been rebuilt a couple of times. This current owner did a terrific job and created truly unique interiors in the older spaces. The side yard and backyard were landscaped to perfection. I added the above diagram which shows each room in the house.

The front porch, living room, dining room, and kitchen are the public spaces in this home. There are two bedroom and two baths. The guest bedroom is adjacent to the dining room. The master bedroom and bath are located to the rear.

I was not planning on writing about this property when I saw it and did not take photos. I wish I had because the adjacent bath and the outdoor shower are truly unique. In a day when most people buy cabinets from Home Depot or Restoration Hardware, it is really refreshing to see homeowners who create unique spaces. In this house, or rather at the rear of this house, the owner created an outdoor shower unlike any I have ever seen. Copper tubing was crafted into an odd-shaped cube with pipes going up and down and back and forth with small outlets for water to trickle down. It is magical.And it is located in a magic garden on the 5450 square foot lot (50' X 109').  If you look at the photo immediately below you will see a door from the master bath next to which the outdoor shower is located.  A second door from the kitchen also leads  to the rear garden to the left side of the rear side addition.  

There is plenty of ground upon which a new owner could add a pool. The yard is delightful as is. Not everybody needs a pool, but if you want one, you can have one. CLICK HERE to view the Key West MLS datasheet and view more photos. Then please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642, to set up a private showing. I am a buyers agent and a full time Realtor at Preferred Properties Key West. This house will not last long. Now is the time to act.

My Secret Love ~ Love Lane, Key West

A visitor to Key West snapped the above photo of 712 Love Lane during an open house and posted it on her Instagram page along with this comment: "Touring a secluded gem on Love Lane that has provided inspiration to many distinguished authors..." with a series of hash tags.  It's wonderful how people who see homes like this just fall in love with Key West.  

Poets and writers have written on the subject of love for centuries. I'm sure that we have all experienced the euphoria of falling in love and some have endured the pain of falling out as well.  Life and Love and complicated. In celebration of Valentine's Day I thought it appropriate to write about one of my favorite lanes in Old Town - Love Lane

 Finding Love Lane can be confusing. There are three separate "Love Lanes" each located near the other but far enough apart to totally confuse just above anyone. If you walk on the north side of Southard Street you will find a Love Lane sign midway between William and Elizabeth Streets. If you walk down the lane you will find that the lane abruptly ends where a house sits and the lane ends. Bur if you are walk on the south side of Fleming Street between Elizabeth and William Streets you will find an unmarked walking lane that begins at the edge of the Monroe County Public Library (which has been referred to as the Pink Library). This, too, is Love Lane. And if you went back to Southard Street and walked on the south side of the street you would find a tiny little walking lane, a lane also called Love Lane. In his book The Streets of Key West author J. Willis Burke explains the confusion about Love Lane:

"Love can generate some confusion - and Love Lane is no exception. Some maps show to Loves, one coming off Fleming and another off Southard, but not meeting mid-block. Other maps indicate Gwynn Street, named for a former mayor and cigar tycoon E. O. Gwynn, is the lane that runs off Southard. And yet another source cites Johnny Cake Lane as making up the northern half of Love Lane. At one time perhaps it did... As confirmed by the loving couple who lives on the Fleming Street side of the lane, both are now called Love Lane. It seems they don't meet because the bungalow that bisects the lane was built on the sly, and over the decades, has been grandfathered and let stand."

I grabbed my camera and took photos of each of the current existing houses on Love Lane. I rummaged through my old shoebox and found photos of Love Lane taken a little over fifty years ago Let's see how much remains the same and how much things have changed. One of the anchor houses for the longest segment of Love Lane is actually numbered 713 Southard Street.  It's a big old unpainted Bahamian House with a large rear yard that abuts Love Lane.  I know there will be hordes of buyers in line to buy this house when the day comes it goes on the market. Until then it will just stand there looking foreboding has it has for decades.

721 Southard Street is the other anchor house. It has been restored and stands proud and tall among the smaller cottage style houses nearby. 

------

Notice the scuttles on the historic metal roof. Scuttles were used to ventilate these homes. Notice also the lack of trees around most of the homes in this block. This was typical of most of Key West until the gentrification of Old Town starting in the 1970s. 

The photo of 717 Love Lane is all that remains of that old house. Today the space is a vacant appendage to 727 Love Lane which has an enormous side yard. Surprisingly, that huge lot has never had a pool added.

728 Love Lane  Key West

 

The north of Southard Street segment of Love Lane abruptly ends at 721 and 722 Love Lane. On the 1889 Sanborn Fire Map the lane veered right (east) for about 40 feet or so and then turned north again where part of the lane was maybe five feet wide at most. Remember this was at a time when nobody had cars and few people had horses. It wasn't until after the end of World War II that many locals even had cars and parking in Old Town was not that big of a a deal. Most of the houses on this segment are both larger in size and also located on larger lots than either of the other two Lone Lane blocks. 

716 Southard Street but this is the south of Southard segment of Love Lane. There is a smaller cottage in the rear.

712 Love Lane 2017

712 Love Lane  Key West

There are two more cottages located behind a fence at the south terminus of this segment of Love Lane.  Although 712 Love Lane now has gated parking, I would bet its pretty cumbersome to get into and out. Love Lane is much more narrow here than the section located off Southard Street.

I think most of the residents in this section of Love Lane probably don't mind walking to their cars. Their lives are removed from much of the hustle and bustle going on out on Fleming Street. The Monroe County Library acts as a nice little buffer.  When they walk down the lane the rest of their world is an oyster. All roads lead to someplace far away and exotic.  I personally think living on a lane called Love would be pretty satisfying. There are no current home listings on Love Lane. But there will be - sometime. Maybe this is a location you could fall in love with as well.