923 Eaton Street - Old Town - Key West

Just Listed!, but not by me, 923 Eaton Street in the Old Town area of Key West, Florida.  If you are a frequent visitor to Key West, you have surely driven or walked by 921 and 923 Eaton Street,  the two side-by-side gems that rival the famous "Painted Ladies" of San Francisco. Although not as elaborate, the Key West Ladies speak to the simplicity of design that characterize many of the houses in the Old Town area.  In his book The Houses of Key West Alex Caemmerer wrote "What particularly impressed me at that time, although many of these houses were small and owned by people of modest means - mostly local workers, they had a simplicity of line and an aura aura of elegance and dignity which had the same effect on one as does, for instance, a simple Bach tune."

Now you may think my comparison of the Painted Ladies in San Francisco to the more modest Key West Ladies is a stretch. You might be correct but consider that Alex Caemmerer selected the modest house at 921 Eaton Street as the cover photo for his book about Key West houses.

921 Eaton Street as photographed in 1965

923 Eaton St as photographed in 1965

Who would have thought that these two simple little houses owned by locals of modest means would become iconic representations of Key West architecture. But that is what they did. Now, the sad fact is that between the time Alex Caemmerer immortalized 921 Eaton Street and the recent Recession, the two ladies fell into disrepair as both properties were foreclosed upon. You can see that the new owner of 921 Eaton Street has started a restoration of that residence. The new owner of 923 Eaton Street just listed this property for sale at the asking price of $499,000.  The listing Realtor describes the new listing this way:

"Put your Fantasy parties on hold and get your offer in ASAP as this historic home in Old Town won't last! Perfectly livable home within a couple blocks to the Seaport is ready for you now, or your upgrades to make this a gem sparkle and shine! Rare, huge,fenced, back yard complete with brick pavers, allows for expansion of existing home AND pool AND pool/guest house. Dade county pine galore and beautiful new hard wood floor in spacious living room, front porch, upgraded baths and kitchen, separate indoor laundry room. Bring your best offer as this one won't last at this price! Truly a Fantasy surprise you won't want to miss out on."

 

The Monroe County Property Records date the construction of both 921 and 923 Eaton Street at 1906. I experienced frustration today trying to access the historic Sanborn Fire Maps for Key West and was unable to enlarge a particular file which show 923 Eaton being in place in 1889.  I saw a house at that location for that date, but I was unable to decide with reasonable certainty that it is the same house. But I am pretty sure it is.  This little area is located near the Historic Key West Seaport which is located just two blocks to the north.  Many of the old homes in Key West are located in this area because the earliest residents of Key West lived here near their work - the seaport.

No matter the exact date it was built, the fact is the 923 Eaton Street has the earmarks of a really old house and includes lots of Dade County Pine walls, ceiling, floors, traditional windows, scuttles on the second floor roof, etc. The house was updated around 1988 from what I can determine in the Property Records.  It looks to me like the an interior wall or walls in the front part of the house were removed to create the current living room.  A new addition was added to the rear where the kitchen was updated, a bath and laundry added, and a large combination dining/family room with modern sliding doors were added. The back yard was bricked-in and some landscaping was added. A bathroom was added to the second floor as well. I assume all renovations were done at the same time. What was in style 25 years ago now looks tired and needs updated or maybe replaced.

The constant feature of this property is the historic character of the original house and the very large (deep) back yard where there is room for a large pool or maybe a smaller pool a a guest cottage.  CLICK HERE to view the Key West Association of Realtors mls datasheet. 

If you would like to see 923 Eaton Street please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642. I am a buyers agent and a full time Realtor at Preferred Properties Key West. Let me help you find your place in Paradise.