Dazed & Confused over Short Sales?

If you have read my blog for a while or watch the movement of properties on the Key West Association of Realtors website you will see that some short sale properties seem to sell quite quickly and that others seem to languish. If you are dazed and confused by the process, the paragraphs that follow may offer some interesting insight on what some listing agents, renters, and owners do that impact why some properties sell and why others do not.

1. Some real estate agents seemingly do not understand the point of a short sale is to assist a troubled property owner to sell his/her property to a buyer for an amount less than the seller owes to his lender(s) on the condition that the lender(s) agree to accept that lesser amount in full satisfaction of the loan. The seller benefits from not having a foreclosure on his/her credit record. The lender benefits if the amount received outweighs the potential costs of foreclosure and consequent re-marketing of the property.

Here's the rub. Some real estate agents continue to price short sale properties at ridiculously high asking asking prices. I'm talking about per square prices that make no economic sense. The point of a short sale is to sell the property before it gets foreclosed, not to create an impediment (illogical pricing) that deters sane buyers from even looking at the property.

2. Conversely, some real estate agents price properties almost too cheap so that they (listing agents) can sell the property quickly. It is interesting to see how many properties get listed as short sales only to go "contingent" within a day or so of being listed. I believe this is helping to drive down the value of similar properties in the same areas. This is especially true in some condominium developments in Key West.

3. I've seen some listing agents deny that that the seller needs to negotiate the price or sell the property even though it is listed as a short sale. I recently submitted an all cash offer on a short sale property where the listing agent denied it was a short sale (even though it was listed that way in the mls). The agent even told me not to submit an offer less than a certain amount. The agent said the seller was only a few payments behind, yet I knew the lender had filed a Lis Pendens on the property months ago. The offer got rejected and a few days later the seller's agent substantially increased the asking price!

4. Many of the short sale properties in Key West are not owner occupied. In fact, many are rented. For some reason renters seem more in control of what gets sold than the owners or their real estate agents. Renters control when the properties can be shown, and what they look like and smell like. Renters usually demand at least 24 hours notice to show. Some renters refuse to show specific rooms even when proper notice is given. Dogs and cats (and their lingering odors) can make an otherwise nice place look or smell like hell. I have smelled pet urine in several short sale properties.

Some agents are never quite able to get potential buyers in to see listed properties. They may not have keys or the owner does not want the tenants to know the property is listed for sale less the tenant would stop paying rent to the seller. Restated: the property is listed for sale but cannot be shown. Make offer sight unseen.

Consider this as well. Owner rents a large house to a renter for let's say $2000 per month. Tenant then sublets each bedroom and even creates additional bedrooms by partitioning off "rooms" to create makeshift bedrooms. A three bedroom single family house suddenly becomes a five or six room boarding house. If you think I'm making this up, you are wrong. There are sure to be many beasts in the house as well. When a property owner no longer cares about what happens to the property, all animals are welcome. (Not all animal owners are bad. But some are!)

I've shown my buyers short sale properties that are rented. My buyers ask who gets the rental income. Not the lenders, dear readers. Even though most mortgages have an assignment of rents provision, few lenders exercise the right to collect the rent. In most situations the defaulting borrower (Seller)continues to collect rent until the property is foreclosed or sold in a short sale. One owner I know stopped making mortgage payments right after Hurricane Wilma in October 2005 and rented the house until last year. Now a relative lives in the property. There is no incentive to really sell when an owner continues to collect rent or lives in the property for months on end.

5. I've seen instances where people that sell real estate may be assisting sellers in depriving lenders from maximizing their recovery. Example number one: real estate agent lists a short sale house at an aggressively low price. Seller and Buyer (who might be a relative like a brother in law or cousin) enter into a Contract of Sale and Purchase. The short sale is then processed through the system without the lender having any knowledge that the "Buyer" is actually an insider of the Seller. Seller ends up staying in the property after it is sold to the relative as a "renter" or tenant. Example number two: Seller offers a short sale property that has an ancillary asset with a special value (such as an occupational license or furniture in a vacation rental property) that was purchased with the loan proceeds. The listing agent does not include the "asset" in the mls listing but does let it be known that the special asset can be purchased separately outside of the real estate closing. Wink! Nod!

6. Another instance can occur when the seller engages a negotiator to facilitate the short sale on behalf of the seller with the lender. The seller requires (as a condition of signing the Contract of Sale with the buyer) that a certain title company write the title policy and close the transaction. Seems harmless enough, except that the title company is run by an insider of the negotiator and charges fees in excess of what a local title company in Key West would charge. And when the lender demands the real estate agents reduce their commissions in order to close the transaction, the negotiator's fee remains unchanged.

Most of the short sale properties are straight-up offerings. It is not my intent to suggest anything otherwise. But there are instances where a few real estate sales people, renters, and property owners take actions that confound the process.

Open House(s) Sunday - Key West

Attention Bargain Hunters: Preferred Properties Coastal Realty Inc. is holding another Big Open House Event on Sunday, March 8th between 1:00 PM to 3:00 PM. CLICK each of the addresses below to preview the homes you may want to visit.

1334 Atlantic Boulevard which is a specactular Ocean-front residence with its own pool. Offered at $2,495,000.

1015 Eaton Street in Old Town is charming Eyebrow house with 4 bedroom 3 bath home with a fireplace, new kitchen and baths, & private pool and spa. Unlike a lot of Eyebrow houses, this one has "real" bedrooms. They are large and have lots of headroom. This place is Done! Done! Done! This is a SHORT SALE Offered at $995,000.

807 Washington Street is a newly constructed three story town home featuring 3 bedrooms 3.5 baths, heated pool, & parking. All of this and located in the Casa Marina area but within walking distance to Duval and the beaches. Offered at $1,800,000.

1404 South Street in the Casa Marina area is offerd at $995,000. There are two master suites, a beautiful pool and tropical garden.

3509 Eagle Avenue is a spacious home on a large lot. The main house had 3 bedrooms 2 baths plus a guesthouse with one bedroom and one bath. Offered at $799,000.

I will be hosting the OPEN HOUSE at 1015 Eaton Street. Please stop by to say hello and keep me company. Actually, I'm expecting about 100 prospective buyers. There are lots of lookers in town.

If you are interested in buying a house, condo or town house in Key West and haven't found the right place at the right price, CLICK HERE to search the Key West MLS database. No Realtor will call or start sending you emails. It's your way to see what is available and at what price. Prices have dropped and sellers are being reasonable in their negotiations. If you see a property you like, please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. Who knows, you might end up owning a place in Paradise.

Key West Condo & Townhouse Short Sales - 1

It is that time of the month again to haul out the unsold Key West Condos and Townhouses that are offered by the sellers as "short sales". Just so nobody thinks that I am misleading the Public into thinking these are my listings: they are not! These are all listings in the Key West MLS that you can search on your own. CLICK HERE to search the Key West mls to your hearts content. There are many good deals out there and I encourage buyers to invest some time in separating the deals from the "no-deals".

The group I am providing today are units in the Old Town, Casa Marina, the Meadows, and the Midtown areas. CLICK HERE to see the units. They are listed alphabetically by street. Spend the time and compare pricing per square foot, amenities offered, age and quality of construction, and monthly or quarterly management fees. Each property is different from all others so you have to do your homework to figure out the price and location that may work for you.

Some of the units have Transient Licenses. Those units without a transient license may be legally rented as a monthly vacation rental. There are rules that govern different areas so let's just say look for the property that you like and then figure out what type of rental opportunities may be available to you if you decide you want to rent your unit.

I will do another list of condos and townhouses in the burbs of Key West in a couple of days.

Let me encourage serious buyers to take the current downturn in the market seriously. I think there are some good buying opportunities on some nice properties. If you see something you like, make a serious offer. The better your offer, the more likely you are to get it accepted by both the seller and the lender(s). Turn the downturn into an investment opportunity for yourself.

If you happen to see a property that appeals to you, please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642, or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com and ask for more information.

January Real Estate Sales in Key West

I've been telling you that sales are picking up in Key West and advising you not to wait too long before you buy. Snoozers are Losers!

In January there were ten single family home sales in Key West (including a couple of properties that could be used as legal duplexes). Going either way is common in Key West, I guess. I have written about several of the homes that sold and I gotta tell you, I told you they were bargains to be had. Included were 701 Elizabeth, originally $1,579,000 and sold for $695,000 (Not a Short Sale nor a distress sale); 3 Pinder Lane, originally listed for $1,390,000 and sold for $900,000; 716 Olivia Street (originally listed for $2,895,000 and sold for $1,025,126 in one day). The buyers on the above referenced properties made excellent buys in my opinion. A major Key West house sold that was listed for $6,495,000 and sold for $5,700,000.

There were eight condo and townhome sales during January. Four of those were identified as either bank owned properties or short sales. Among the winners of that group are a unit at 1075 Duval with a real transient license. It sold for an incredible $439,774. A third floor bank owned unit at Sunset Marina with a terrific water view sold for $399,000. And a two story townhome at Windward Park sold for just $400,000.

Even, perhaps, more interesting is the number of contingent and pending single family and duplex properties in Key West. Fifty-three properties are now under contract. Of that number, 26 are shown as short sales and 11 were identified as bank owned properties. In case you think that all short sales are crappy little houses that could not be sold CLICK HERE. The incredible house at 811 Southard is a short sale and somebody snagged this big one. I wrote about 1212 Olivia CLICK HERE. It is a bank owned house on a really nice block. I showed that house twice within a couple of hours of when it was listed. (Just as in the case of the sold bank owned home at 716 Olivia CLICK HERE (scroll down to October 27th) mentioned above under single family sales, this unit reportedly went for a little more than the asking price just so that the buyer could seal the deal.)

Finally, thirty one condos and town homes are shown as contingent or pending sales. Of that number, 15 are short sales and 6 are bank owned properties. The most notable in my opinion is the gift at 1118 Olivia Street that was listed at only $359,000. CLICK HERE to see what I wrote about that property that went under contract just 4 days after being listed.

You need to be aware that there is some confusion about how to classify houses and condos that have signed short sale contracts. Not all properties that have signed short sale contracts are listed as such. I believe the number of actual contingent and pending sales is much, much higher. But that is just my opinion.

Buyers who are not in Key West have a bit of a disadvantage to those people who happen to be here when new properties get listed or when prices are reduced. But that should not stop you from using your computer to do some research and using your noggin to figure out if a particular property could work for you. You probably know what you want and what you can afford. I encourage potential buyers to search the real Key West Association of Realtors mls database CLICK HERE to see what kind of property they can buy for the money they want to spend. Always look at properties priced higher than you can afford and search properties with less space or amenities than you require. CASH is KING and you may be able to negotiate a real sweet deal, just like some of the lucky buyers mentioned above.

Let me, Gary Thomas, help you buy your place in Paradise. Please either call me at 305-766-2642 or 3-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. Tell me what you want and how much you want to pay. You might own a place in Key West where you can snooze on the beach.

No Brainer Loans

A few years back when buyers were buying properties in Key West as second homes or investment properties, some of the local banks helped create part of the financial predicament we are experiencing today. They made what I like to call "No Brainer Loans".

I first heard the term "No Brainer Loan" about 4 or 5 years ago. It was used by a local banker I'll call "Big-wig". I had called him to discuss a property my buyer had found that needed renovation. I needed to find out what kind of financing my buyer could obtain. Big-wig told me the bank had a program where the bank would loan money to purchase the property and renovate it. The bank would require two appraisals. One would value the property "as is" when purchased. The other would value the property after the construction was completed. (This appraisal would be done based on architect plans, budget guidelines, and appraiser assumptions. The bank would over-see the construction and pay the contractor and materialmen.)
Big-wig's bank would the convert the purchase-construction loan into a permanent mortgage and "save" the buyer-borrower from additional mortgage expenses later on down the line.) The buyer-borrower would still need some cash, but the amount of cash was diminished by the assumption that the finished property would be worth far more money later on. Everybody was supposed to get rich on this scheme. Big-wig said with assurance something to the affect "It's a no brainer for me."

I never had a buyer that took advantage of Big-wig's offer. My buyers always dug into their piggy banks and borrowed the rest.

The loan option proposed by Bib-wig was akin to the "bigger fool theory" of investing in my opinion. CLICK HERE to read short Wikipedia explanation of the bigger fool theory. Several local banks did the same type of loan or a variation thereof. So I'm not picking on any one lender.

I have seen a lot of properties either get foreclosed or offered for sale on a "short sale" basis that were or are owned by local Key West residents. Many of these properties were investments. The banks created the tools with which both locals and out of towners could buyer property and renovate the same. That is a good thing. But both the lenders and borrowers should have had their heads examined to find out before hand that neither party had any business participating in a "No Brainer Loan".

If you are hoping to find a place to call your own in Paradise, please consider calling me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. CLICK HERE to search the Key West mls database. If you see something you like, give me a call or send me an e-mail. Let's use our brains and make you dream come true.

Bank Owned Properties - Key West

It's that time again to list the current single family houses and multi-units that are bank owned and offered for sale. CLICK HERE to checkout the current inventory. If you have been following my little blog for some time,you will note that some of the properties are no longer available. Some actually get sold. Some sales take forever to occur, and others can occur very quickly. You may see that several of the properties have had the asking prices reduced.

Some buyers mistakenly think banks are so over-whelmed with the inventory of foreclosed homes that the banks are aching for offers just to sell the houses. Not true. I used to work for a couple of major Denver banks and one of my duties was the management and sale of bank owned real estate. Banks are methodical and make business decisions based on appraised value of the asset, holding costs (taxes, utilities, fees, etc.), real estate commissions, final closing costs, and date of closing. All of those factors are used to determine the "bottom line".

Banks rely on Broker Price Opinions and appraisals to set the asking price and to determine the acceptability of an offer. Appraisals are backward looking. The appraisal uses sales data from prior sales to help determine the present market value. This can be really difficult in a declining market such as the one we are experiencing in Key West.

Banks are adverse risk takers. I recommend that buyers write simple offers with limited contingencies. The less complicated the offer and the quicker the closing, the more likely the offer is to be accepted or countered. Ridiculous offers (price, terms, delayed closing, contingencies on selling other properties, etc.) generally will not be considered.

A lot of the properties banks acquire through foreclosure end up in the bank's portfolio because the prior owner could not sell the property. Key West buyers know that some blocks or areas are not as desirable as other areas. Busy streets are almost always a hard sell. Some houses have structural issues, deferred maintenance, prior flooding, bad neighbors, etc. Those factors can significantly impact the ability to sell in any market but make sales in a depressed market really difficult.

There are two commercial bank owned properties currently available. One is a combination of commercial Duval Street frontage and transient rental accommodations. The second property is a condominium development on Stock Island that went astray. CLICK HERE to checkout those two commercial properties.

Some bank owned properties come with sales incentives or even bank financing offered by the bank owner. Read the fine print on each listing shown on the links to see what incentives may make your purchase more attractive.

If you see a property you like please cal me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com to arrange a showing or to request more information.

1118 Olivia Street - Old Town - Key West Cottage

This is how the listing Realtor describes the Key West cottage located at 1118 Olivia Street: "Bank Owned. REO. Bank Foreclosure. Easy to see! One of a 7 unit condo compound on Olivia Street in Old Town Key West. It is a stand alone structure with vaulted ceilings, tiled floors, stained glass, and a covered rear deck. Brick walkways, large heated pool, landscaping, and a great entertainment area pool side add to the charm of this compound . It is located within biking distance to the beach and the downtown area. Located less than one block off White St where you will find restaurants, gym, galleries, food stores, many local shops and the famous, monthly Walk on White. Parking! Qualified Buyers may be eligible for Seller financing at below market rates, FHA, and other incentives available where applicable. Fast response from Bank."

The cottage is located in the Lionsgate Condominium Compound. The compound is a group of five houses that share a common pool, a small common area, and off-street parking. With the exception of two buildings that are "duplexes", the other properties were single family homes that were incorporated into the compound.

This house has 851 sq ft of living space under roof and has two bedrooms and one bath. However, one of the bedrooms is on the second level and would be more appropriately called a bonus room rather than a bedroom. French doors lead from the living area onto a private covered read deck and orchid garden. There is an enclosure for the washer and dryer. The house also has hurricane shutters. CLICK HERE for more information and photos of this house and the common area and pool. CLICK HERE for a rear view of 1118 Olivia and the house next door to the east. CLICK HERE to see the front view of the other homes that make up the Lionsgate compound.

The property is five minute walk due west to Duval Street and maybe five minutes to the Historic Seaport. Nearby neighborhood hangouts include the Coffee Mill studio, Key West Island Gym, Faustos Food Palace, Dion's Gas Station and purveyor of great fried chicken (no kidding!), Dog 30 (pet store for pampered pups), a fresh fish place, a bike shop, some Realtors, and lots of small restaurants and Cuban coffee joints. It is a real Key West neighborhood.

1118 Olivia Street has what many second home owners dream of owning: a charming Key West cottage in a good location and a pool. The asking price on this charmer is only $359,000 or $422 per sq ft. This property will not last long, not at that price.

Please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com to arrange a showing or to provide more information.

Key West - Bank Owned - Properties

Believe it or not, there are a couple of pretty nice single family houses that are BANK OWNED and that are now available. CLICK HERE to checkout the properties. (There are a couple of multi-family included because I'm too lazy to do a separate list.) Please take a few minutes and go through the list. There are properties in all Key West locations and in low to moderate price ranges.

If you are looking for a house with a pool, do not skip a property because you do not see a photo of a pool. You need to read the comments or read the mls data sheet. The data sheet should tell the reader whether the property has a pool or not. For some reason some Realtors sometimes fail to upload photos the showoff the finer attributes of some properties. Due your homework and read the list. Drive by the properties if you live in Key West. You may surprise yourself by what you find.

Don't let a street address or a messy front yard deter you from checking out a house if it meets your search criteria. I've been very surprised by a couple of very nice houses on Flagler.

Countrywide owns many of the houses on the above list. Countrywide is offering financing to qualified buyers and is also paying some closing costs on some specific properties. Take the time to find the values and incentives that the bank owners are offering buyers. It's not often that you get an opportunity like this.

Again, CLICK HERE to see a list of single family bank owned homes in Key West.

If you are looking for a building lot or commercial property, CLICK HERE. There is one development lot; a mixed use building on upper Duval Street with commercial space downstairs and transient licensed guest rooms upstairs plus a pool and off-street parking; and a ten unit apartment complex on Stock Island. All are BANK OWNED.

There are only 20 days left for this calendar year. Banks run on numbers. I used to work in a really big bank and one of my jobs was selling bank owned assets. Believe me when I tell you that there is still time left to make a good deal on a bank owned property in Key West. The best time to buy is right now and be able to close by the end of business on December 31st. The reason: it's the end of the quarter and perhaps year end for some banks. The more non-earning assets (foreclosures) they get off their books and turn into cash the better.

Write a real offer. Offer cash and make the offer as clean as possible. If you have to borrow, have your financing pre-approved and be able to move a lightning speed. Most of the civilized world starts to stop working any day now because of office parties and people taking extended days off. If you want a deal now, you are going to have to work to make it happen. But then people who work hard usually end up getting more and better things than those who sit around and carp.

If you want to really buy a place in Paradise and need someone on your side, please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com.

Key West Old Town Sales Report - October 2008

Last month a reader suggested that I report on the sales of just the Old Town area as opposed to all of Key West. I thought his request had real merit since that is the area that is most popular with out of town buyers looking to purchase a property here. So here is my spin on current Key West real estate sales.

I gathered the sales info for the years 2004 through 2008. Pretty simple stuff. And the results are not surprising. The fall months historically are slow months. It usually takes a good 30 to 60 days for a contract to evolve into a closed sale. A contract signed around July 4th might take until late September or early October to close if the buyer is relying on borrowed funds. (Bank approval of the loan application, appraisal, survey, title work, etc. Each item takes time and time enlarges the date for final closing.)

2004 was the base year. We had 9 single family homes close for a total of $7,612,000 or sales at $699 per sq ft in Old Town. There were 8 condo and townhome sales totaling $4,745,000 or $866 per sq ft. Remember there were a lot of "conversions" of larger buildings into condos back then. Interestingly, I counted 7 of the total 17 sales in 2004 as being short sales or foreclosures as of today. The number could be higher because I relied just on properties I know from memory that are in foreclosure.

2005 marked the end of the housing bubble and sales had already started to tighten. In 2006 Key West was still reeling from Hurricane Wilma and the downturn in the real estate market. We did not know then that Key West was only a microcosm of what was transpiring nationally. And I don't think any of us understood the world wide importance of the burst of the housing bubble until late summer in 2008. Sales of single family homes in 2005 dropped to only 3 with a sales volume of $4,590,000 or $876 per sq ft. There were 9 condo sales that year at $8,061,750 or $951 per sq ft.

In 2006 the single family sales increased to 6 with a total of $6,047,500 or $683 per sq ft. There were 4 condo and townhome sales totaling $2,017,500 or $703 per sq ft. Condo prices were dropping more as compared to single family homes.

In 2007 there were 5 single family home sales totaling $5,290,000 at $647 per sq ft. Condo and townhome sales dropped to $640 per sq ft as there were only 4 such sales that totaled only $2,198,000.

And this year, 2008, sales have nose dived. There were only two single family home sales in Old Town. One was in Bahama Village and the other was a brand new house at 408 Grinnell Street that I wrote about on May 21st. I referred to it as a half price sale. Well, it went for less than half of the original asking price of $2,750,000 because it sold for just $1,325,000 or $535 per sq ft. Statistically our two single family solds in 2008 amounted to a whopping $1,700,000 or $398 per sq ft. And condo sales were down as well. There were only two sales in Old Town that totaled a mere $1,310,000 or $724 per sq ft. Interestingly, the larger unit (at Harbour Place) sold for $396,000 less than the seller paid for it four years earlier.

There are currently only 7 single family homes in Old Town shown in our mls as contingent or pending. Several of those are short sales. And there are only 5 condo or townhomes shown as contingent or pending. To make matters worse, 3 of those contracts are for units at Harbour House (the yet to be constructed condo development at the foot of Margaret Street).

I have maintained my optimism that Old Town will recover sooner and more strongly than other areas of Key West. I believe Key West will recover as a whole much more strongly than other areas in South Florida. This is because there is still a demand for homes in Old Town. Buyers are waiting to buy the deals. They are waiting for sellers to get more realistic with the asking and selling prices. To borrow and mangle a line from "Field of Dreams" If you price it right, they will buy.

There are a few really nice properties on the market right now in Old Town. Some are priced correctly as compared to previous prices on a per sq ft basis. Some properties are priced high and some low price per sq ft basis. It is not just the price per sq ft that buyers should consider. Some of the distressed properties cost a whole lot more to build than the asking price. And some of the properties enjoy an excellent location which means to me that they will be worth more long term than other properties that may cost less now on a per sq ft basis.

Sellers who need to sell in this market ought to price their properties based on what they are worth today--not on what the sellers wish they are worth. My advice to sellers is to get an appraisal from a good appraiser. Don't list your property based on what you think it is worth or what your Realtor will list it at simply to get your listing. Don't believe the hype being spread around town that short sales and bank foreclosure sales do not count in valuing property. Those sales are a good percentage of the current sales in Key West. They count. Those are the sales that happened. Don't let your life spin out of control and end up losing your property or your equity by irrationally believing that your property is worth more than it is.

More Single Family Home Short Sales - Key West

CLICK HERE to review a list of single family "short sales" in Key West. This list is not thorough because not all short sale properties are on it. Some local Realtors have failed to identify their short sale properties correctly in the mls database as "short sales" and that prevents the inclusion of those listings in easy searches of our mls.

I have been seeing some very nice and quite expensive houses start to creep into the mix of houses being offered as short sales. Some of the houses on the above list are pretty pitiful. But there are some real nice ones as well. Take the house at 222 Golf Club Drive listed at $450,000. This single family home (not a townhouse) located in The Sanctuary has two bedrooms, two and a half baths and a screened in patio and dip pool. This property was built in 2000 and is in great condition according to listing agent.

A while back I wrote about 707 Washington. It is on this list and the asking price has been reduced to $1,499,000. The surrounding homes are all in the multi-million dollar range. The Washington street property was totally rebuilt in 2004 (basically a brand new house). I think it will likely sell at a much lower price, and this could be a real deal for a contractor with enough cash to take out the existing lender and fund the cost of some minor improvements to the property.

Please checkout the list of short sales and if you see something that interest you, please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642, or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. If you have a specific type of property that you are looking for, feel free to contact me and let's see if I can find that for you.

Key West Bank Foreclosures -- déjà vu All Over Again

It seems like it was only last week that I created a list of current bank owned properties in the Key West area. Well, it actually was last week. There have been a couple of changes so I thought it best to update the list. CLICK HERE to see the new list of single family homes.

Some of the houses in the above list have pools or are located on canals. A couple of the houses are really very nice and are priced aggressively to sell. A couple of the houses owned by local banks in Key West may even qualify for bank financing from the seller at competitive rates. So I suggest you look over the list carefully and not dismiss all of the houses as being dogs. That is not the case.

I did not include teh the above list the numerous condos and town homes in Key West, Stock Island, or the areas up to Big Coppitt Key.

There are two commercial properties investors might want to checkout. One is a mixed us building at 824 Duval. CLICK HERE for limited info posted by the listing realtor. I can provide more detailed info for interested buyers.

The second property is a condo project that did not get completed on Stock Island. Again the listing agent has only put limited info on-line. CLICK HERE to review that info. I am quite familiar with the project. I submitted an all cash offer to the bank that ended up owning this property for an amount near the asking price two years ago this month. The shrewd banker turned down my client's cash offer.

I went to the courthouse earlier this week to checkout a couple of files of pending foreclosures. Just before the judge enters and order authorizing the sale, the party seeking the foreclosure (usually the bank) submits an itemized list of all amounts it claims due on the mortgage including principal, interest, attorney fees, costs, appraisal fees, court costs, legal process fees, escrow reserve short falls, etc. The judge reviews the list and typically enters an Order that becomes a Final Judgment that includes those sums and that amount is what is bid by the foreclosing party at the public auction a few weeks later. The bank wants to load up the costs so high as to prevent some other party from buying the property at sale or inhibiting a party who has a right of redemption from exercising that right. I wasn't surprised to see that the practice has not stopped.

I think there is going to be a huge rally right after the election on November 4th. That happens after every Presidential election. But the stress on markets all over the world will be eased when the US elects its new President. If Obama wins I think European markets will soar. The Europeans hate Bush and the Bush policies. I think they see Obama as a leader who deliver all of us from the abyss. If I am right and the election marks the beginning of the end of the bear market, prices will gradually start to rise. Right now prices continue to drop. So I think now is a really opportune time to buy at or near the bottom of the market.

Want to buy now? Please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642, or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com for more information.

More Bank Owned Key West Properties

A few weeks back I wrote about the new listing at 1119 Von Phister a bank owned property that happens to be right next door to where I live. I totally forgot until yesterday that I almost bought that house in 2004. I had plans to renovate it and sell it for a bunch of money. The house sold quickly after it was listed so I thankfully never got the chance to buy the beast. (I'm not putting that property down. Any renovation becomes a beast in my opinion.)

Today stock markets all over the world have moved steeply downward. The mortgage meltdown has turned into a thermal unclear event. Nobody can really predict what will happen next. But I can predict that things will eventually get better. They always do. I lost a huge amount of money after 911. I went nuts. But I eventually accepted what happened. That's all you can do. Or kill yourself.

Time passes and things do improve. Usually. Take the house on the right located at the corners of Elizabeth Street and Southard Street. The black and white photo is from the 1960s or 1970's. I took the color photo two days ago.

I don't know if we are in a new Depression, but there are a lot of depressed folks out there right now. That's the reason for the big smiley to the right as well. People come to Key West to get uplifted and to relax. And the parachute photo just makes you want to get up in the air and fly.

Here are three links to some recently foreclosed properties in Key West.

Link No. One CLICK HERE is a commercial property at 824 Duval Street. It has two commercial spaces of 1500 sq ft each and 6 one bedroom, one bath fully furnished transient rental apartments. There's a pool and tropical garden plus off street parking for eight cars. Bank owned and financing may be available.

Link No. Two CLICK HERE This is a bank owned condominium project that did not quite get completed. Listing agent says it needs about $200,000 worth of work to complete.
It's located on sunny Stock Island. Bank owned.

Link No. Three CLICK HERE This is a group of several homes that are bank owned. I've written about the house on Go Lane and 1119 Von Phister. Our office has the listing on the architecturally "interesting" A frame at 2301 Linda (corner of Flagler) which has a big pool and a small price per sq ft ($168) for the property. Each house is bank owned. Bank financing may be possible on Go Lane and Von Phister only.

If any of these properties look interesting to you, or if you have a specific property that you are looking to find, please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com.

The Flim-Flam Short Sale

One of the better morality movies from the 1960's was George C. Scott's The Flim-Flam Man. He played Mordecai Jones - a penny-ante con man that rode the rails and took the money of Southerners. "You can’t cheat an honest man" was his motto. But he had no trouble cheating would-be cheaters.

I have seen several properties that have been offered as "Short Sales" in the Key West Association of Realtors MLS that are Flim-Flam. Flim-Flam can be defined as "a trick or deception, especially a swindle or confidence game involving skillful persuasion or clever manipulation of the victim".

The concept of a Short Sale is pretty simple. A home owner needs to sell his house quickly because of some impending situation such as a potential foreclosure, illness, marital conflict, etc. So Seller lists the property at a price he hopes will attract a potential buyer. In turn, the Seller hopes his lender will agree to accept a discounted payoff of his mortgage (an amount less than what is owed). If this occurs, the seller theoretically walks away from his problems and resumes a somewhat normal life without the burden of whatever precipitated the need to sell.

The above scenario is playing out with more regularity now across America. It pre-supposes the seller, the buyer, and the lender are each acting in good faith with respect to their competing interests in the sale of the specific property and the potential forgiveness of some portion of the debt. The parties negotiate their best deal based on their competing interests and submit an offer to lender to approve the deal. At that point the lender usually gets Broker Price Opinion (maybe a drive by appraisal by a local Realtor who estimates the fair market value of the property in the given market). Assuming the broker's opinion supports the contract price, the lender would then order a full appraisal and start the process to obtain final approval under the lender's credit authority to accept the discounted payoff.

I have seen a few sellers that have properties listed as Short Sales that are pulling a flim-flam on their lenders. This is how it is done. Seller lists his property for sale at a ridiculous price for a given market. In Key West the asking price might be somewhere around $1000 to $1300 or more per square foot for a nice house in Old Town, The Meadows, or The Casa Marina Area. There are very few houses that would sell for those prices in the current Key West real estate market. Yet the seller dictates the high listing prices.

Let's imagine that the seller owns several such properties in Key West. Let's further imagine that seller has each property rented. Let's assume that the tenants pay their utilities and that they send their monthly rent checks directly to the would-be seller. For grins sake we'll assume the seller gets $2000 per month net on each house. Let's make the scenario more interesting. Let's assume that the seller has not made a mortgage payment to his lender(s) since July 2006. If my math is correct the seller would have collected 26 months rent of $2000 per month for a total of $52,000 (for each house) without making any payment to the lender.

Let's add a different dimension. Let's assume the seller lets the "tenant" control when the house can be shown. A lot of tenants "work nights" so that means showings can only occur during certain hours and usually require at least 24 hour advance notice to tenants. The more impediments the seller or his tenant establish to limit the showing the short sale property the more likely there will be no offer on it. Likewise, the higher the asking price, the less likely the property will be shown because buyers are looking for deals not ordeals.

Here's another wrinkle some would-be sellers have devised. They require the listing Realtor to exclude certain parts of the real property from the sale. Examples could include that shiny new Viking stainless steel stove and refrigerator, or that ornate crystal chandelier, or whatever. Those are usually items that were in the property when the seller bought it or added to the property through renovations paid for by a loan on the property. Even though the mortgage covers these new fixtures as becoming part of the real estate, I've seen many sellers treat them as their own private property which they can keep as a souvenir of the once treasured house. And nobody is going to stop them.

The sellers who are achieving short sales in Key West are the ones who have listed their property for sale at a price that is targeted for this current market. The price is not related back to a time when the house may have sold for a higher price nor even to an old appraisal. An appraisal that is more than a year old is worthless in my opinion.

Almost every mortgage I have seen has an assignment of rents provision in it wherein the borrower agrees to give the lender any rents he collects in the event of default on the mortgage. Lenders typically don't enforce this and the borrowers (sellers) keep the rent. So it is not in the interest of a flim-flam short seller to get a short sale accomplished.

If you think I am exaggerating or making something up, you are wrong. There are a bunch of people in Key West who own several properties that are collecting rent but who are not paying their mortgages or taxes. There is no reason to do because they know they will lose the property at some point in time. In the meantime, they get to pocket the loot. We may cheer that the banks are getting hosed by these flim-flam would-be short sellers. But when you consider the "Bailout" or what the President now calls "Rescue Package", we are collectively letting the flim-flam short sellers take money out of our pockets.

And this tidbit may get you a little miffed at the tenants. They often claim to be abused by the awful landlords. Many eventually stop paying rent when they figure something is up. That can occur when the property is listed for sale or when the sheriff posts a public notice on the door advising the property is subject to foreclosure. If the tenant holds over and does not vacate the new bank owner must file an eviction. That costs more money and takes more time. So some banks give up to $1500 in relocation money to tenants to get them to leave without being evicted. Again, it looks like the taxpayers are going to help subsidize this into the future as well.

There are many good and decent people that are facing real adversity right now. My point is not to make lite of their predicament. Their pain must be awful. It just riles me that there are some really devious people that continue to use the system to their own advantage even as they sink into mire.

Bank Owned Homes in Key West

I just created a new list of Bank Owned Homes in the Key West area. Homes from Old Town up to Sugarloaf Key. CLICK HERE to checkout the list. I must add that the list does not contain all bank owned properties. Some Realtors have not entered all of their listings in the mls. Some out of town Realtors (like some from Tampa and Miami) have access to our mls but do not necessarily follow our rules and don't always get their listings entered correctly.

There are some dogs on the list. Some of the houses have had the kitchen appliances and even the kitchen cabinets removed. Some need more than a little "TLC". But there are a few really nice homes that are priced very aggressively. The bank owners want to sell those houses. A couple of the houses are located on water. What a treat: a good deal and a water view.

Here are a couple of tips to help make your offer attractive to the guy at the bank that decides whether to accept your offer. First, have cash or get pre-qualified to purchase any on which you intend to make an offer. Most lenders require proof of funds or a pre-approval letter on file before they will even look at an offer. Two, don't clutter your offer with extraneous conditions that the bank (seller) will not consider. The bank is selling only what it got through foreclosure. It will warrant title and nothing else. Do your inspections before you make your offer because the bank will not re-negotiate the deal after it has agreed to a sales price. Three, offer to close within thirty days. In a world of multiple buyers, don't plan on dragging your closing out. Finally, even though the lender will usually pay for the title insurance, you may want to engage a local real estate attorney to represent you at the closing. Don't let a good deal turn into a bad one by being penny wise and dollar foolish.

If you are looking to purchase a bank owned property in Paradise please consider working with me. I used to manage bank foreclosures for two banks in Denver. I have the real world experience to help you present an offer to the bank owner that may have a good chance of getting accepted. Call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. Who knows, we may get the better of Mr. Potter!

Key West Short Sale Opportunities

A Short Sale occurs when a property is sold and the lender agrees to accept a discounted payoff, meaning the lender will release the lien that is secured by the property, upon payment of of an amount less than is actually owed.

In yesterday's blog I reported that about one-half of the single family home and condo sales in Key West were either short sales or bank foreclosures. Short sales occur when troubled borrowers try to sell the property prior to foreclosure in hopes of salvaging part of their credit worthiness. Many short sales fail but others are succeeding. So I thought it might be helpful to explain how they work from a buyer's perspective.

Some sellers identify their property as a short sale to attract buyers. Some of those sellers aggressively price the property at or near the price they think the lender may accept as a discounted payoff amount. Other sellers keep the asking price in line with other homes in the geographic area but advise potential buyers to submit their best offer. In this current market I would suggest you look for property you like first then try to determine if there is a real bargain to be made in buying it. There are too many properties on the market just to look for a "bargain". Look to buy value first then make the bargain happen through negotiation.

The asking price and selling price are not always the same or even near the same even in short sales. In a competitive market seek to make your offer as a buyer better than all other offers. That does not mean you have to offer the most money. (1) If you have the ability to do so, make an "all cash" offer. Submit proof of funds (letter from your bank showing more than $X in your account or provide a copy of your most recent bank statement or stock brokerage account showing value of liquid assets) to cover the transaction. (2) Obtain written pre-approval from a lender showing that you can obtain a loan to purchase the subject property within a limited period of time. (3) Do not encumber your offer with unnecessary contingencies. Instead, make your offer as simple as possible. (4) Offer to close the transaction by the end of the calendar month if possible. Make your offer help the bank's performance look better by getting the deal done by month end.

Some Realtors will tell you that you do not need to have an earnest money deposit to make an offer to purchase. That may be true in some instances. But if you want to get a bank's attention, have real money on deposit with a title insurance company or an attorney who will write the title insurance policy. I suggest that you offer to pay for the title insurance. By so doing you eliminate one sticky point in any negotiation. Lenders are seeing a lot of short sale offers that disappear because some Realtors are submitting offers on multiple properties. Having real cash on a specific property may make your offer look better than an offer that is just written on paper.

Once you have a signed contract between seller and buyer, the short sale offer is submitted to the lender (or lenders if there is more than one mortgage). The listing Realtor or short sale negotiator will submit a HUD One form to the lender. That form will show the net proceeds the lender will receive should the short sale be approved. It is a good faith estimate of all charges and fees that seller and buyer will incur to make the deal happen. You are more likely to get a contract approved if there is just one lender or if one lender has both a first and second mortgage. If some outside party has a mortgage of other lien junior to the first mortgage, that other party must also agree to the short sale. That may require a nominal payment to that party. If that party does not agree, a short sale cannot occur.

Assuming that the HUD One Statement is acceptable from a numbers standpoint, the lender will first order a BPO, Brokers Price Opinion. ("The BPO is a tool used by lenders and mortgage companies to value properties in situations where they believe the expense and delay of an appraisal is not necessary. Real estate brokers are given an order to do a BPO by the lender, mortgage company or loss mitigation company. The broker does either a Drive By BPO or an Internal BPO in most cases.") If the numbers still look attractive, the lender will probably order a full appraisal to validate the proposed deal. Once the appraisal is returned the lender will do internal math calculations and obtain departmental approvals of the short sale amount. It is almost like doing a loan approval in reverse. Here the lender must substantiate the deteriorated property value to justify the write off of a larger loan. When approved, the lender notifies the parties that they may close the deal and give them a limited period of time to do so.

Some lenders have gotten their acts together and have become able to get deals approved within a few weeks. That usually happens when sellers have all of their documents in order and when there are no extraneous requirements to complicate a proposed deal.

Be flexible. Be willing to work with the seller if need be to get the deal accomplished. I've seen several sellers who listed properties at what I think is an aggressive low price agree that agree to sell at an even lower price. Sometimes things crop up between the contract date and closing that make closing look almost impossible. Different lenders have different requirements to approve short sales. Some require a cash payment from seller to permit debt forgiveness for the balance. Others may require the seller to sign a promissory note. Perhaps something happens to the property that requires the contract terms to be restructured. Be flexible. If you are getting a good deal, do not be a hog. Pigs get fat. Hogs get slaughtered.

I created a very simple list of single family short sale properties in Key West. There are more properties but the often listing Realtors may not have entered the information in our mls database correctly for easy capture. CLICK HERE to review the easy single family short sale list. CLICK HERE to review the condo and town home short sale list. If you are looking for a particular type of property or have a specific location, please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642, or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. Let me know what type of property that you want, your price range, and the time frame in which you want to get a deal completed. Maybe I can help you. I can try.

Out of Business

Those of you who come to Key West know the Pegasus Hotel at the corner of Southard and Duval Streets. There are several store front shops on the Southard Street side including the now Out of Business Psychic. The Psychic of all people should have seen the downside--you'd think.

It's that time of the month again. Time to recap what happened in the Key West real estate market for the month of September 2008 and to compare it with the same time for previous years.

I've said before I am not a numbers guy. I guess I'm in the wrong business because numbers are really important in real estate. Anyway, in 2005 there were 23 single family home sales in Key West totaling $27,454,266. The number dropped to 14 sales in September 2006 with sales of $9,730,000, and fell further to 5 sales in 2007 for only $4,386,500. In 2008 we had 20 sales totaling $12,026,000. We are improving, right? Yes and no. Our sales are up over 2006 and 2007 but they are only 44% of what they were in 2005. Five of the 20 single family home sales were bank foreclosures and 5 were short sales. So one half of our market was distressed property. And I think several of the remaining sales were distressed but not characterized that way because of the way they were marketed.

In 2005 there were 12 condo and town house sales that totaled $8,326,000. That number fell to only 6 sales in 2006 with sales of just $2,728,000. In 2007 the number bounced back to 11 sales of $9,421,000. 2008 produced 11 sales of $3,414,000. Looks bad, right? Maybe. Maybe not. Six units at the high end Key West Beachside Resort closed in September 2007 and that drove prices very high. If those sales are eliminated, there were five market sales of condos totaling just $1,885,000. So it sort of looks like we improved over condo and town home sales over years 2006 and 2007 this year, but we are near the number of sales for the year 2005. But our sales price are off by 59% over what they were in 2005. Out of the 11 condo and town home sales we had in September 2008 3 were bank foreclosures and 3 were short sales. So, again, distressed properties made up at least half of that segment of the market again.

I just checked the Key West Association of Realtors website. There are 1116 residential units for sale in the Key West area. That number does not include timeshares. There are still plenty of people looking to buy in Key West. I know some have decided to hold off doing anything until the uncertainty in Washington and Wall Street clears. As if that is ever going to really change. If the Psychic who went out of business across the street from our office is any indicator of predictor of what the future holds, don't believe anybody who tells you what the future beholds. They don't know. But past behavior is a good predictor of future behavior.

We have been improving year over year. We will not go back to the price levels of 2005 for some period of time. But our sales volume in terms of numbers of units sold is progressing to the same level. That is encouraging even if prices are down. But down prices are good for buyers who got sold out of the pricier market. So now some people who missed the earlier price ride are in on the ground floor of what may become another rise in prices. Who knows? The Psychic is Out of Business.

Other People's Money

I don't like the idea of a bank bailout one bit. It will reward incompetence and greed. It will not teach anyone anything other than that Big Brother will come to the rescue of those who have power and influence. It will cost taxpayers an unimaginable amount of money and lost opportunities.

The Wall Street mavens created this mess by screwing with private home ownership and turning it into investment vehicles that could be bought, sold and traded at a profit (or a loss). The mavens got rich and earned incredible salaries, bonuses and stock options based on the their production. The mavens got theirs. And now the taxpayer is being told we have to make everything better for the common good. Hooey!

Now the Bush Administration is asking the public to go into tremendous debt so that our large financial institutions do not fail. The Administration is raising the specter of mass financial ruin if we do not act now.

What if several real big banks and a lot of small ones were to fail? What if the remaining investment banks were to fail? I know three things would happen for sure. One: the assets would be marshaled and sold to pay creditors.
Two: the stockholders equity would be wiped out. Three: the unsecured or under-secured might get nothing. But the insiders in the banks who created the mess for the institutions would lose all the equity they had in the companies by virtue of stock ownership.

Let's get up close and personal and look at the mess from Key West. Without naming names let me relate a couple of tales that may cause you to question the rationale of a bailout.

Local bank "A" was an aggressive local lender in the Key West market. It made residential and commercial loans. Since it is not a large bank, it had to participate a portion of some loans to larger upstream lenders. That is a common practice among banks to spread the risk. Bank "A" made no qualification loans based on cash down and appraised value upon build-out of the finished property. The assumption was that the market would continue to grow and that the new structure could be sold at a profit. The bank would fund the cost of acquisition, construction, and provide interim financing until the building was completed and sold. The front end and completed appraisals would be used to justify the loans. That scenario does sometimes work in a perfect world.

Local Bank "B" made aggressive loans including one development loan that was used to convert a group of apartment buildings into condos. I'll call this development "Howard's End". I used to work for a couple of big banks in Denver and did commercial loan workouts. One of the first things I'd do when I got a new credit (problem loan) was to read the Credit File and the Collateral File. The Credit File tells you the story of who the borrower is and the purpose of the loan.

The Collateral File contains the documents (loan commitment sheet, deeds, mortgages, notes, security agreements, assignments of rents, UCC filings, etc.) that secure the lender's position on the property (the "collateral"). Most banks have a loan administration department or loan review department that reviews collateral files to make sure that every required document was properly executed and recorded to insure the bank's position is perfected in the event legal action or foreclosure becomes necessary.

I personally did not like the location of Howard's End, and I thought that the workmanship was marginal. When I saw the project two years ago it was about 70% complete. The entire project flooded during Hurricane Wilma and a lot of the work that had been done needed to be repaired. Local Bank "B" had turned off the money supply to complete the project and used the loan reserves to continue paying interest on the construction loan. By so doing Bank "B" did not have to recognize a potential bank loss by writing down a portion of the loan. In essence the bank was advancing new money to hide the eventual loan loss. (I base this on what the developer told me personally. I have no independent verifiable knowledge.)

The developer somehow deeded one unit a new owner and got a title company to insure title. It is my recollection that Local Bank "B" did not get any money from the sale of that unit but that the developer got the cash.

The deal is more complicated because Local Bank "B" did not properly collateralize its loan. It did not have a first mortgage on all of the buildings or ground that makes up the complex. As a result there were competing parties with conflicting legal priorities on different buildings that make up the project. The result was that even if Bank "B" were to foreclose its mortgage, it would not end up owning all of the buildings and all of the ground. At least two different parties owned individual units or a portion of the underlying ground that prevented access to other parts of the property.

As I recall Local Bank "B" had about a $2 million loan to the developer. A private party had a second mortgage of around $500,000 and then there was that buyer who somehow got to purchase a unit inside the complex before a certificate of occupancy was issued or the condominium documents were recorded. Do you see the problem here dear reader? If you do, would you agree with me that such incompetence should not be rewarded by bailout? Shouldn't the bank fire the moron that created this mess. Shouldn't the shareholders in Bank "B" suffer a dilution of their investment for hiring such incompetent people? Where is the responsibility and accountability for management if managers let bankers hide problem loans and let collateral clerks fail to properly secure a loan? Maybe small banks should not exist if they cannot perform the required functions correctly.

Local Bank "A" doesn't get off any easier. That bank profited by charging huge fees for originating and booking its loans in the Go-Go years before 2005. Local Bank "A" and its officers and its directors made calculated bets that they could grow the bank by making aggressive loans. They bet wrong in several notable instances. Local Bank "A" has had to foreclose on mortgages it held and now must try to sell its foreclosures in a declining market. And it has more foreclosures in the pipeline. Neither management personnel nor style has changed.

I know my rants and raves won't stop anything in Washington. But if you are old enough to remember the Junk Bond fiasco of the 1980's and the S&L collapse in the 1990s you may share my disdain for what is being proposed today. Once again the public is being asked to reward the Wall Street players (and small hometown banks like the two I mentioned in Key West) that took huge risks with other people's money. I could care less if the Wall Street players lose their homes in the Hamptons, Aspen, Boca or anyplace else. They did not earn that wealth. They took it. It's time for payback.

1119 Von Phister St. - Key West - Bank Owned

This foreclosure stuff is starting to get personal. Just Listed: 1119 Von Phister Street in the Casa Marina Area of Key West. I'll be your lucky neighbor. I live next door. These are neighboring homes CLICK CLICK CLICK CLICK.

Let me tell you about the house and why I think it is a great buy. And let me tell you about the neighborhood and why you might just want to live there.

The original house is constructed of Indian Blocks, a building material used in maybe 30 of the older homes in Key West. The man who owned the house before the last owner added room after room during a time when there either was no building code or there was no enforcement of building codes. The lot is huge and the house and the structures on the lot were many and very strange. That man passed away and when the most recent owners bought the house the additions and contraptions were removed. What was left was the core of the original house and a huge lot. Other than the exterior walls in the front, everything is new.

The recent owner was a perfectionist and demanded that everything be constructed perfectly. No matter the cost. Much of the inside was hand crafted elsewhere and on spot. As a result I don't think you will find this home to be filled with materials available at Home Depot or Lowes. 1119 Von Phister is in a class of its own.

Click each word or phrase to see parts of this home: Greatroom -- Great room and dining alcove -- Kitchen -- Pool and rear deck -- Pool and spa -- View from second floor front balcony
-- Bath second floor front -- Master bedroom and sitting room -- View from master bedroom -- Master bedroom balcony -- Master bathroom -- First floor front bedroom -- First floor bath

The house is aggressively priced to sell now at $1,895,000 or at $666 per sq ft. For you readers who like to pick at prices I would suggest you consider the quality of the finishes and the size of the lot before you carp over the per sq ft price. I think the price is aggressive because it is priced below a two week old appraisal. The price shows the bank owner wants to sell this property now. And if you read the fine print in the link below you will see that the lender-owner may offer Seller Financing.

There is a huge old Mahogany tree at the front of 1119 Von Phister. I have one in front of my house and there are several others on our block. Many of the houses are quite old but renovated. The block looks stable, as in real people who take care of their homes live here. The house is a five minute walk or take a bike ride to the Atlantic Ocean and the beach. This is the real deal my friend. And the good thing is you won't have any sand in your feet by the time you walk back home. Of course you can ride your bike or drive your car or scooter.

You can also walk or bike over to Duval Street(5 minutes); or go down to the shops on White Street like Faustos or go to the Island Gym and watch me lift weights in the early morning (2 minutes): or you can grab a cafe con leche at any of the several neighborhood joints. You can be at the Historic Key West Seaport as fast on your bike as in your car (if you consider parking in your travel time) (5 minutes). And you can be in the Key West suburbs at the shopping centers or leave on a jet plane (we got 'em) at the Key West International Airport, all within a 5 minute drive from 1119 Von Phister. We don't have Conch Trains and motorcycles going through the area. We don't have noisy bars and noisy tourists walking home at four o'clock in the morning singing songs or arguing about how much they love or hate each other. We are so close and yet so far away.

CLICK HERE for more details and photos of 1119 Von Phister Street.

Bank Owned Houses in Key West

It's that time again. Time to roll out the list of Bank Owned Single Family Homes for sale in and near Key West. CLICK HERE to look at the list of active single family homes. Some are "challenged" and a couple actually look really interesting.

I used to manage the Special Assets Department for a bank in Denver. We had our share of bank foreclosures. Banks don't want them. A lot of lenders have been doing some aggressive restructuring in the form of short sales to limit the amount of new foreclosures. But there will still be more foreclosures for some time to come.

One of the reasons for some of the foreclosures in this post is the location of the houses or the condition of the houses. Some of the properties are located in areas that took water during Hurricane Wilma. Buyers have to buy the property in an "as is" condition and I think a lot of prospective buyers are fearful that a property that flooded once will flood again. Wilma was a catastrophic event and the flooding that occurred was totally unexpected based on previous history. At least that is what I have been told. But the fear factor is keeping some of these houses from being purchased. I assume there is a price where prospective buyers will feel the price is worth the risk.

Some previous owners have made the sale of bank foreclosures a bit more difficult as well. Several of the properties I have seen (including some on this list) have been cannibalized. Cannibalized means that someone has taken appliances, light fixtures, air conditioning systems, kitchen cabinets, etc. I guess the former owners think they paid for the stuff and they wanted to take some memento to remember their former home. Yea, that or sell the stuff and make a few bucks.

On a lighter note I would suggest that potential buyers look at 1525 Niles Channel Road ($999,900) with awesome open water views, 4 Go Lane in Key West ($990,000) located on an active Key West canal with easy deep water access [photos to the Right are of Go Lane], and 67 Bay Drive on Saddlebunch Key ($583,900) which is affordably priced and it also has open water views. [The mls listing info is not correct on Bay Drive. The price of $583,000 is correct as of 8-26-2008.]

These properties are vacant and easy to show. If you would like to see one and maybe get a good deal on a bank foreclosure please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com.

Last week I wrote about the deal that was. The deal that got away and that will not return. A real deal in a down-trodden economy.

Yesterday two properties sold and closed. Our office used to have the listings on both properties, but lost them when the properties did not sell. They were not my listings, but those of this office. No harsh feelings, I'm working with one of the owners on another deal. So what I am about to write is not sour grapes or anything like that. But it is intended as illustrative of what is going on in Key West at this time.

Remember what life was like after September 11th: all of the uncertainty and the feeling of having been savagely violated. I remember that the Key West community came together like no time before or since. Everybody was nicer. Kinder. More caring. We did not know what was going to come next. The tourists stayed away in droves. Fantasy Fest did occur, but it was not like before. And then everybody left town and we waited for Christmas. The Christmas crowds arrived and then, like gangbusters, everybody started buying property. Prices soared as inventory shrank. Money was cheap and plentiful and the buying spree was on.

The effect on prices was that homes that a couple of years before that sold around $250 per square foot shot up to near $1000 per square foot. And many sold in or near that price range. Even crap. Forget about who caused it for point of discussion. It happened.

Fast forward to 2005 and the beginning of the downturn in the real estate bubble nationally. Add the awful summer of four hurricanes in Key West and the crippling of our tourist business. Hurricane Wilma through everybody for a loop because for once Key West actually got hurt by a hurricane. Normally it is just a bunch of wind and rain and falling tree limbs or an occasional tree that falls on a house. But Wilma was different. It was a real hurricane and it did real damage.

Christmas in 2005 came and I think we all assumed it was going to be like it was in 2001 after the memories of 9/11 started to subside. Wrong. There was resistance to buying in general and resistance to price in particular. But there were sellers who thought that the market would bounce back and many resisted reducing prices.

We listed 730 Passover Lane in January 2006 for $795,000 or $1338 per square foot. The owner had the property appraised and priced the property a little higher. My assumption is that the owner might have thought that would give some downward negotiating ability. I held numerous open houses there and many folks just loved the property. There were two detractions to the property: it only had one bedroom and there was no room for a pool. Oh, yeah, the price was way high. Nobody made an offer. Nada. The price eventually got reduce, but only to $599,000 in mid 2007.

The owner listed the house with another company in February 2008 at $579,000 and progressively dropped the asking price. The last asking price was $499,000. The property sold at $430,000 or $724 per sq ft for the 594 sq ft cottage. CLICK HERE for more info on 730 Passover Lane.

The Artist House guest house at 534 Eaton Street is a Key West landmark. We listed that property in December 2005 at $2,975,000. Guest houses are traditionally listed like hotel rooms or by the number of "keys" or "rooms" available to be rented. Since many guest houses have phantom units, rooms without required transient licenses, pricing can sometimes get difficult. Key West banks have no problem loaning money to purchase guest houses, but they typically only loan on legal units and discount any phantom units even though everybody knows the phantom units produce income. The fact is that phantom rooms could be shut down by city code enforcement so those rooms just don't count. The Artist House had six rooms plus an additional room and not the required number of transient licenses.

In November 2007 The Artist House was listed with another real estate company for $2,600,000. It sold yesterday for $2,130,000. It was a short sale. The price per room or key was about $300,000. That was a good price considering that there are more rooms and transient licenses, but it falls in line with what pricing on other units has been or should be. CLICK HERE to see what you missed buying.

I think there are some who will see these prices as still being too high. There are some readers who may want some sellers to be punished even more by even larger price reductions. There are some short sales in progress that are waiting to close. I am not sure that the prices will cause the market to drop that much even though I am pretty certain that the price per square foot on some future sales will be lower.

If you CLICK HERE and search the Key West mls database you will see that there are two Key Wests. First there is Key West's Old Town area full of cute cottages and majestic conch houses. Second is the Key West Mid Town and New Town areas. Many of the houses in those areas were damaged during Hurricane Wilma. Many of the condos and town homes were sold at inflated prices and are now bank owned or offered as short sales.

There just are not that many really nice properties remaining for sale in Old Town.
Sellers who do not need to sell do not have their properties on the market. If a property is listed for sale in Old Town it is probably listed because it needs to get sold. But with a shrinking base of available properties I don't know that the prices will necessarily get depressed much more.

But the Mid Town and New Town areas are the reverse. The inventory of available properties is still large. I read the Monroe County Clerk's website and see all of the new properties going into pre-foreclosure. It is not stopping. So prices in those areas will likely continue to drop until this mess is over.

If you want to catch the big one before there are no more big ones left, CLICK HERE to search the Key West mls database. If you see a property you like please call me, Gary Thomas, 305-766-2642 or e-mail me at kw1101v@aol.com. Let me help you find your little (or BIG) place in Paradise.





'